Where would you locate the tribal community in the Varna system of India? Discuss.
10 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Tribal communities stand largely outside the varna system: they were not ranked as one of the four varnas, had their own religions, kinship and land systems, and the Constitution treats them as a separate category under Article 342; yet sociologists have shown a continuum, as some tribes were absorbed as castes through Hinduisation, Sanskritisation or Rajputisation, so their place varies from outside to the margins of the caste order.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Discuss the different scholarly positions on tribes and varna, with examples, and give a reasoned conclusion.
Answer outline
Introduction
Varna is the fourfold scriptural scheme of Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Shudra; tribes are communities with distinct territory, culture and relative autonomy from the caste order.
Outside varna
- Tribes typically have egalitarian clan-based structures and lack ritual hierarchy of purity and pollution.
- Constitutional status: Scheduled Tribes are notified under Article 342; Lokur Committee (1965) criteria included primitive traits, distinctive culture, geographical isolation, shyness of contact and backwardness.
On the margins or inside
- Srinivas held that semi-tribal groups such as the Gonds, Oraons and Bhils also underwent Sanskritisation; anthropologists also speak of Kshatriyisation and Rajputisation.
- Gond chiefs adopted caste-Hindu practices and claimed Rajput, and so Kshatriya, status, claims the British supported.
Contemporary debates
- Assertion of distinct indigenous religions such as Sarna and of Adivasi identity.
Conclusion
Tribes are best placed outside varna, with a historical continuum of absorption into caste that should be studied, not presumed.
Examples and data to cite
- In 2020 the Jharkhand Assembly unanimously passed a resolution seeking a separate Sarna religion code in the 2021 Census.
Facts to remember
- Article 342 empowers the President to specify Scheduled Tribes after consultation with the Governor.
- Lokur Committee report 1965.