Pratidin
2026 · Statistics Optional Paper I · 15 marksMainsQuestion 8b

A population of N = 4 units has values y₁ = 10, y₂ = 20, y₃ = 30 and y₄ = 40. Consider a sample of size n = 2 without replacement with inclusion probabilities proportional to a size measure xᵢ, where x₁ = 1, x₂ = 2, x₃ = 3, x₄ = 4. The inclusion probabilities are taken as
πᵢ = nxᵢ/∑xᵢ; i = 1, 2, 3, 4
(i) Suppose the selected sample is {2, 4}. Using Horvitz-Thompson estimator, estimate the population total.
(ii) Given the joint inclusion probabilities π₂₄ = 0·3 for units 2 and 4, estimate the variance of Horvitz-Thompson estimator and comment on the possibility of negative variance estimate.

15 marks · directive: Estimate

Answer

The core of a good answer

πᵢ = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, so Ŷ_HT = 20/0.4 + 40/0.8 = 50 + 50 = 100; the Horvitz-Thompson variance estimator gives 2000 − 333.33 = 1666.67, while the Sen-Yates-Grundy estimator gives 0 (since y₂/π₂ = y₄/π₄); the HT form can be negative when πᵢⱼ < πᵢπⱼ and the cross term dominates, whereas the SYG form is non-negative when πᵢπⱼ ≥ πᵢⱼ, as here (0.32 ≥ 0.3).

An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work

What the question asks

Compute the inclusion probabilities, then the HT estimate ∑yᵢ/πᵢ over the sample. For the variance estimate, apply the Horvitz-Thompson unbiased variance estimator (and, for a fixed-size design, the Sen-Yates-Grundy form), and discuss when each can be negative. Marks 7 + 8.

Answer outline

Introduction

∑xᵢ = 10, n = 2: π₁ = 0.2, π₂ = 0.4, π₃ = 0.6, π₄ = 0.8 (sum = 2 = n). Sample s = {2, 4}; π₂π₄ = 0.32, π₂₄ = 0.3.

Part (i): HT estimate

Part (ii): HT variance estimator

Part (ii): Sen-Yates-Grundy estimator

Comment

Conclusion

Ŷ_HT = 100 (exactly the true total). The variance estimate is 1666.67 by the Horvitz-Thompson formula and 0 by the Sen-Yates-Grundy formula; the latter is the sensible one here and cannot be negative under the stated condition. Arithmetic checked in Python.

Examples and data to cite

Facts

Facts to remember

Sources used for the explanation

Write a timed answer in the app