Illustrate how you will partially confound a 2⁴-factorial experiment into 2² blocks in 2 replicates with no main effects confounded. State the confounded effects in each replicate.
10 marks · directive: Illustrate
The core of a good answer
Divide each replicate of 16 runs into 4 blocks of 4 by confounding two independent interactions and their generalised interaction: Replicate I confounds ABC, BCD and AD; Replicate II confounds ABD, ACD and BC; no main effect is confounded, and each of these six interactions is estimated from the replicate in which it is not confounded (relative information 1/2).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Four blocks per replicate means three degrees of freedom (three effects) are confounded per replicate: two chosen interactions and their generalised interaction (product with squared letters deleted). For partial confounding the sets must differ between replicates, and none of the six may be a main effect. Then construct the key (principal) block and the other blocks, and state the confounded effects.
Answer outline
Introduction
2⁴ = 16 treatment combinations of factors A, B, C, D; 2 replicates; each replicate in 4 blocks of 4 plots.
Step 1: Choice of confounded effects
- Replicate I: generators ABC and BCD; generalised interaction ABC × BCD = AB²C²D = AD.
- Replicate II: generators ABD and ACD; generalised interaction = A²BC D² = BC.
- None is a main effect, and the two sets are disjoint.
Step 2: Blocks of Replicate I (by parity of letters in common with ABC and BCD)
- Block 1 (key block): (1), bc, abd, acd.
- Block 2: d, ab, ac, bcd.
- Block 3: a, cd, bd, abc.
- Block 4: b, c, ad, abcd.
Step 3: Blocks of Replicate II (parity with ABD and ACD)
- Block 1 (key block): (1), ad, abc, bcd.
- Block 2: a, d, bc, abcd.
- Block 3: c, ab, bd, acd.
- Block 4: b, ac, cd, abd.
Step 4: Check
- Every combination in the key block of Replicate I has an even number of letters in common with ABC and with BCD (e.g. abd shares a, b with ABC and b, d with BCD).
- Other blocks are obtained by multiplying the key block by a combination not in it (mod 2).
- Block contents were generated and checked in Python.
Step 5: Analysis
- ABC, BCD, AD are estimated from Replicate II only, and ABD, ACD, BC from Replicate I only: relative information 1/2 each.
- All four main effects and the other interactions (AB, AC, BD, CD, ABCD) are estimated from both replicates with full information.
- d.f.: blocks 7, treatments 15, error 31 − 7 − 15 = 9.
Conclusion
Replicate I confounds ABC, BCD and AD; Replicate II confounds ABD, ACD and BC. No main effect is lost, and every effect is estimable from at least one replicate.
Examples and data to cite
- A common alternative plan: Replicate I confounds AB, CD, ABCD; Replicate II confounds AC, BD, ABCD, which keeps the highest-order interaction totally confounded. Choice depends on which interactions the experimenter can most afford to lose.
Facts to remember
- Number of effects confounded with 2^q blocks = 2^q − 1; here 3.
- Generalised interaction: product of two effects with squared letters dropped.
- Key block: combinations with even parity with every generator.
- Partially confounded effect estimated only from replicates where unconfounded.