Explain the uses and limitations of Index Numbers.
Calculate Laspeyres’, Paasche’s and Fisher’s Indices for the following data :
Commodity | Time Period I: p₁ | q₁ | Time Period II: p₂ | q₂
A | 10 | 2 | 15 | 1
B | 15 | 3 | 10 | 3
C | 20 | 4 | 15 | 4
Also, examine whether Paasche’s and Fisher Index Numbers satisfy (i) Time Reversal Test, and (ii) Factor Reversal Test or not.
15 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
With Σp₁q₁ = 145, Σp₂q₁ = 120, Σp₁q₂ = 135 and Σp₂q₂ = 105, Laspeyres = 120/145 × 100 = 82·76, Paasche = 105/135 × 100 = 77·78 and Fisher = √(82·76 × 77·78) = 80·23; Paasche fails both the time reversal test (P₁₂ × P₂₁ = 0·940 ≠ 1) and the factor reversal test (P × Q = 0·681 ≠ value ratio 0·724), while Fisher's ideal index satisfies both (product 1 and P × Q = 105/145 = 0·724).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Three parts: uses and limitations of index numbers, computation of the three price indices with period I as base, and algebraic plus numerical checks of the time reversal and factor reversal tests for Paasche and Fisher.
Answer outline
Introduction
Base period I (p₁, q₁), current period II (p₂, q₂). Laspeyres uses base quantities as weights, Paasche current quantities, Fisher the geometric mean of the two.
Uses
- Measure changes in price level and inflation (CPI, WPI), deflate nominal series to real terms (real wages, real GDP).
- Adjust wages, dearness allowance and pensions to cost of living.
- Compare output (index of industrial production), trade volumes and share prices over time or places.
- Guide economic policy and business forecasting.
Limitations
- Based on samples of items and markets; selection and weighting are subjective.
- Quality changes, new products and changing consumption patterns are hard to reflect.
- Different formulae give different answers; no index satisfies all tests.
- A general index may not represent any particular group; comparisons over long periods lose validity.
Step 1: Aggregates
- Σp₁q₁ = 20 + 45 + 80 = 145
- Σp₂q₁ = 30 + 30 + 60 = 120
- Σp₁q₂ = 10 + 45 + 80 = 135
- Σp₂q₂ = 15 + 30 + 60 = 105
Step 2: Indices (period I = 100)
- Laspeyres P_L = Σp₂q₁/Σp₁q₁ × 100 = 120/145 × 100 = 82·76
- Paasche P_P = Σp₂q₂/Σp₁q₂ × 100 = 105/135 × 100 = 77·78
- Fisher P_F = √(P_L × P_P) = √(0·82759 × 0·77778) × 100 = 80·23
Step 3: Time reversal test (P₁₂ × P₂₁ = 1)
- Paasche: P₁₂ × P₂₁ = (Σp₂q₂/Σp₁q₂)(Σp₁q₁/Σp₂q₁) = (105/135)(145/120) = 0·9398 ≠ 1: fails.
- Fisher: P₁₂ × P₂₁ = √[(Σp₂q₁/Σp₁q₁)(Σp₂q₂/Σp₁q₂)(Σp₁q₂/Σp₂q₂)(Σp₁q₁/Σp₂q₁)] = 1: satisfied.
Step 4: Factor reversal test (P × Q = Σp₂q₂/Σp₁q₁)
- Value ratio V = 105/145 = 0·7241.
- Paasche: P × Q = (105/135)(Σq₂p₂/Σq₁p₂ = 105/120) = 0·6806 ≠ 0·7241: fails.
- Fisher: Q_F = √[(135/145)(105/120)]; P_F × Q_F = √[(120 × 105 × 135 × 105)/(145 × 135 × 145 × 120)] = 105/145 = 0·7241: satisfied.
Conclusion
Laspeyres 82·76, Paasche 77·78, Fisher 80·23 (prices fell). Fisher's index satisfies both reversal tests, which is why it is called the ideal index; Paasche (and Laspeyres) satisfy neither. Computed in Python.
Examples and data to cite
- Most official consumer price indices use a modified Laspeyres-type formula, with weights from household budget surveys.
Facts to remember
- P_L = Σp₁q₀/Σp₀q₀; P_P = Σp₁q₁/Σp₀q₁; P_F = √(P_L P_P).
- Time reversal test: P₀₁ × P₁₀ = 1.
- Factor reversal test: P₀₁ × Q₀₁ = Σp₁q₁/Σp₀q₀.
- Fisher's index satisfies both; Laspeyres and Paasche satisfy neither.
- Laspeyres tends to overstate and Paasche to understate price change because consumers substitute towards goods that become relatively cheaper.