Write on the following in about 150 words each :
(b) How is excretion different from osmoregulation in mammals?
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write on
The core of a good answer
Excretion removes metabolic wastes, chiefly nitrogenous waste as urea in mammals, along with carbon dioxide and other toxic by-products, while osmoregulation keeps the water content and solute concentration of body fluids constant; in mammals both are done largely by the kidney, but they have different aims and controls (ADH and aldosterone for osmoregulation).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define each, then compare them by purpose, substances handled, organs and control, ending with how they are linked in the nephron. A comparison table suits a 150-word note.
Answer outline
Introduction
Excretion is the elimination of metabolic waste; osmoregulation is the active regulation of body fluid osmotic pressure to keep water and electrolyte levels stable.
Excretion in mammals
- Mammals are ureotelic: ammonia from amino acids is converted to less toxic urea in the liver by the urea cycle (Krebs and Henseleit, 1932).
- Kidneys filter urea and other wastes from blood into urine; lungs remove carbon dioxide; the liver and skin also contribute.
- Aim: remove substances that would be toxic if they built up.
Osmoregulation in mammals
- Hypothalamic osmoreceptors sense rising plasma osmolality; vasopressin (ADH) from the posterior pituitary acts on V2 receptors in the collecting duct to insert aquaporin-2 channels, so more water is reabsorbed.
- Aldosterone and angiotensin II, with ADH, are among the hormones that control water balance.
- Aim: balance water and ions, not remove waste.
Key differences
- Purpose: waste removal versus fluid and ion balance.
- Main substances: urea, CO2 versus water, Na+, Cl-.
- Control: largely continuous filtration versus hormonal feedback (ADH, aldosterone).
- Link: excretion of solutes needs water, so osmoregulation decides how concentrated the urine is.
Conclusion
The kidney performs both jobs at once, but excretion is about what is removed and osmoregulation about how much water and salt is kept.
Examples and data to cite
- Diabetes insipidus: reduced vasopressin release or reduced kidney response to it causes polyuria and hypernatraemia, a failure of water balance.
- The urea cycle spends three ATP (four high-energy phosphate bonds) per turn.
Facts to remember
- Mammals are ureotelic.
- ADH acts through V2 receptors and aquaporin-2.
- Osmoreceptors in the hypothalamus detect plasma osmolality.