Pratidin
Polity and governance14 November 2026The Hindu, Opinion, Page 6GS2

Op-ed: Split the Supreme Court into a constitutional court and regional appeal courts

In one line: An op-ed argues that the Supreme Court should become a small constitutional court in Delhi with regional appeal courts below it, because adding judges has not cut its backlog.

Published 14 November 2026. Written by Pratidin from the reports linked at the end; every fact checked by a separate review before publishing. How we work

An opinion article in The Hindu argues that the Supreme Court can only recover its role as a constitutional court if it is restructured. It proposes a lean Constitutional Court of about 11 judges in Delhi to hear constitutional questions and substantial questions of law, and four or five Regional Courts of Appeal to hear ordinary appeals. The article says pendency crossed a record of about 92,000 cases by the end of 2025, and that adding judges has not helped: the sanctioned strength was raised to 34 in 2019, when pendency was near 60,000, and to 38 in 2026, yet the backlog kept rising. The 2026 increase came through an ordinance of 17 May 2026, later replaced by the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Amendment Act, 2026.

The article contrasts the early 1960s, when Constitution Benches decided about 134 cases a year, with the last decade, when they decided fewer than 10 a year. It blames the growth of Special Leave Petitions under Article 136, meant as an exceptional remedy, which it says has turned the Court into a routine court of appeal. It relies on Article 130, which lets the Court sit in Delhi or at other places the Chief Justice of India appoints with the President's approval, and on the Law Commission's 229th Report (2009), which proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches. It says a Parliamentary Standing Committee endorsed regional Benches in 2023, and that a 2016 reference on a National Court of Appeal, in V. Vasanthakumar v. H.C. Bhatia, has stayed unheard for a decade.

The article draws on other countries: the U.S. Supreme Court hears about 1% of roughly 7,000 petitions a year, with 13 federal Courts of Appeals below it; South Africa has a Constitutional Court in Johannesburg and a Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein; Germany has a separate Federal Constitutional Court; Brazil in 2004 required a 'general repercussion' before hearing constitutional appeals. The counter-arguments are well known. Successive Chief Justices have resisted splitting the Court, fearing it would become 'less supreme'; critics say regional courts may be seen as lesser forums and could invite forum shopping. The article replies that the Court already sits in small Benches that sometimes give conflicting rulings.

Practise this in the app: flashcards, quiz and a timed answer
Prelims

Prelims facts

  • Article 130: the Supreme Court sits in Delhi or at other places the CJI appoints with the President's approval.
  • The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches.
  • The Supreme Court's sanctioned strength rose from 34 to 38 (including the CJI) in 2026, first by an ordinance of 17 May 2026.
  • Article 136 lets the Supreme Court grant special leave to appeal from any court or tribunal in India, except military tribunals.
  • In 2016, a Bench referred the idea of a National Court of Appeal to a Constitution Bench in V. Vasanthakumar v. H.C. Bhatia.

Quick recall

Which Article lets the Supreme Court sit outside Delhi?
Article 130, if the CJI so appoints with the President's approval.
Which Article gives the Supreme Court power to grant special leave to appeal?
Article 136.
Minimum Bench size for a substantial question on interpreting the Constitution?
Five judges, under Article 145(3).
Which Law Commission report proposed regional Cassation Benches?
The 229th Report (2009).
Sanctioned strength of the Supreme Court after the 2026 amendment?
38 including the CJI (37 plus the CJI).
Who fixes the number of Supreme Court judges?
Parliament, by law, under Article 124(1).
Which 2016 case referred the idea of a National Court of Appeal to a Constitution Bench?
V. Vasanthakumar v. H.C. Bhatia.
Where do South Africa's Constitutional Court and Supreme Court of Appeal sit?
Johannesburg and Bloemfontein respectively.

Prelims practice question

Under which Article of the Constitution of India can the Supreme Court sit at places other than Delhi?

  1. Article 124
  2. Article 130
  3. Article 136
  4. Article 145
Show answer

Answer: (b) Article 130. Article 130 says the Supreme Court shall sit in Delhi or in such other place or places as the Chief Justice of India may, with the approval of the President, appoint. Article 124 deals with establishment and constitution, Article 136 with special leave to appeal, and Article 145 with rules of court.

Use this in UPSC Mains: previous-year questions

Recurring theme: Structure and functioning of the higher judiciary, pendency and judicial reform

  1. 2023 · GS2 · 10 marksCovers one partUse it in the conclusion

    "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment.

    How to use this

    Argue that judicial independence also depends on the Court having the institutional capacity to decide constitutional questions promptly.

    • Constitution Benches reportedly decided about 134 cases a year in the early 1960s but fewer than 10 a year in the last decade.
    • The 229th Law Commission Report (2009) proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches to protect this role.
Also asked on this theme
  1. 2013 · GS2 · 10 marks

    The Supreme Court of India keeps a check on arbitrary power of the Parliament in amending the Constitution. Discuss critically.

  2. 2014 · GS2 · 12.5 marks

    Starting from inventing the 'basic structure' doctrine, the judiciary has played a highly pro active role in ensuring that India develops into a thriving democracy. In light of the statement, evaluate the role played by judicial activism in achieving the ideals of democracy.

Mains practice question

"Adding judges has not reduced the Supreme Court's backlog." In this context, examine the case for regional Benches of the Supreme Court and the objections to it. (250 words)

Model answer

The Supreme Court's sanctioned strength rose from 34 in 2019 to 38 in 2026, yet pendency is reported to have crossed about 92,000 cases by end-2025. This has revived the idea of dividing its work.

The case for regional Benches

  • Constitutional basis: Article 130 lets the Court sit elsewhere with the CJI's decision and the President's approval, so no amendment may be needed.
  • Expert backing: the 229th Law Commission Report (2009) proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches; a Parliamentary Standing Committee endorsed regional Benches in 2023.
  • Constitutional focus: Constitution Benches reportedly decided about 134 cases a year in the early 1960s but fewer than 10 a year in the last decade.
  • Access to justice: litigants far from Delhi bear high costs of a final appeal.
  • Comparative practice: the U.S., South Africa and Germany separate constitutional and appellate work.

Objections

  • Successive Chief Justices have resisted, fearing a divided Court would be "less supreme".
  • Regional Benches may be seen as lesser forums and invite forum shopping.
  • Conflicting regional rulings could fragment the law declared under Article 141.
  • Without filtering Special Leave Petitions under Article 136, new Benches may simply fill up.

Way forward

  • Decide the 2016 National Court of Appeal reference (V. Vasanthakumar v. H.C. Bhatia).
  • Frame admission criteria for Article 136, like Brazil's 2004 'general repercussion' filter.
  • Keep a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi.

Structural reform, paired with discipline over what the Court admits, can let it act as a true constitutional court.

The basics

Why this matters

How the Supreme Court is built, and what it is allowed to hear, is core GS2 polity. The debate on splitting the Court has run for decades, and it returns whenever pendency rises. Knowing the Articles involved, and the committees that have studied the idea, is enough to write a strong answer.

What the Supreme Court does

The Constitution gives the Supreme Court several kinds of work. Some cases begin there; most arrive on appeal.

The Supreme Court's jurisdiction
  1. 1Article 32Writs to enforce Fundamental Rights
  2. 2Article 131Original jurisdiction in disputes between the Centre and States
  3. 3Articles 132 to 134Appeals in constitutional, civil and criminal cases
  4. 4Article 136Special leave to appeal from any court or tribunal
  5. 5Article 143Advisory opinion on a reference by the President

Article 136 is the widest door. It lets the Court hear an appeal from almost any judgment, at its discretion. It was meant for exceptional cases, but special leave petitions now make up much of the docket. Article 145(3) says that a substantial question of law about interpreting the Constitution must be heard by at least five judges, a Constitution Bench.

Who sets the number of judges

Article 124(1) lets Parliament fix the number of judges by law. The Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956 does this.

Sanctioned strength of the Supreme Court (including the CJI)
  1. 19508 judges
  2. 198626 judges
  3. 201934 judges
  4. 202638 judges, first by ordinance of 17 May 2026

The proposal to split

The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) suggested a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four Cassation Benches in the north, south, east and west for ordinary appeals. The idea relies on Article 130, under which the Court can sit outside Delhi if the Chief Justice of India so appoints with the President's approval.

One Court or two tiers?
For splitting
  • Frees senior judges for constitutional cases
  • Cheaper access for litigants far from Delhi
  • Used in the U.S., Germany and South Africa
vs
Against splitting
  • May make the Court 'less supreme'
  • Regional rulings could conflict
  • May invite forum shopping
fewer than 10
Constitution Bench decisions a year in the last decade, as cited in the op-ed
Against about 134 a year in the early 1960s, according to the same article.

For the legal detail, see Article 130 and the seat of the Supreme Court and Article 136 and special leave petitions.

Go deeper

Why it matters for UPSC

Judicial pendency, the structure of the Supreme Court and comparison with other constitutions are all GS2 themes. The relevant Articles (124, 130, 136, 145) and the 229th Law Commission Report are standard Prelims material.

The core idea

The Supreme Court was designed as a court of constitutional questions and of serious appeals. Over time, discretionary appeals under Article 136 and special leave petitions have filled its docket. The op-ed argues that Article 130 and the seat of the Supreme Court already allows Benches outside Delhi, as the Law Commission's 229th Report proposed. A separate question, how many judges the Court should have, is settled by Parliament under the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956.

Numbers and dates to remember

  • Pendency: about 92,000 cases by end-2025, a record, as cited in the op-ed.
  • Sanctioned strength: 34 in 2019; 38 in 2026 (ordinance of 17 May 2026).
  • Constitution Bench decisions: about 134 a year in the early 1960s; fewer than 10 a year in the last decade (as cited).
  • 229th Law Commission Report: 2009.
  • National Court of Appeal reference: 13 July 2016.

Where to go next

Go deeper: one Court or two tiers?

The case for change. The op-ed's central claim is that size is not the problem; jurisdiction is. Strength rose from 34 to 38, but the docket grew faster. Because the Court sits in Benches of two or three judges, it can give conflicting rulings, and constitutional questions wait. The Law Commission's 229th Report in 2009 proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches, and the op-ed says a Parliamentary Standing Committee endorsed regional Benches in 2023. Because Article 130 and the seat of the Supreme Court already allows sittings outside Delhi, supporters argue no amendment is needed.

The case against. Successive Chief Justices have resisted a split, fearing a divided Court would be "less supreme" and that regional Benches would be treated as lesser forums. Critics also worry about forum shopping and about regional Benches declaring conflicting law, which matters because Article 141 makes the Supreme Court's law binding on all courts.

The unresolved question. In 2016, in V. Vasanthakumar v. H.C. Bhatia, a Bench framed questions on whether a National Court of Appeal could be created and referred them to a Constitution Bench; the op-ed says the reference has stayed unheard for a decade.

A middle path. Some argue the real lever is admission discipline under Article 136 and special leave petitions. Brazil's 2004 reform required a "general repercussion" before constitutional appeals could be heard. The U.S. Supreme Court hears about 1% of roughly 7,000 petitions a year. A filter like that, combined with a permanent Constitution Bench, could achieve much of the benefit without dividing the Court. Changing the Court's size remains a matter for Parliament under the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956.

Article 136 and special leave petitions

The discretionary appeal that dominates the Court's docket.

In one line: Article 136 lets the Supreme Court, at its discretion, grant special leave to appeal against any judgment or order of any court or tribunal in India.

What it says

Article 136(1) gives the Court power to grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order passed by any court or tribunal in India. Article 136(2) excludes courts or tribunals constituted under laws relating to the Armed Forces. The power is discretionary: a litigant has no right to special leave, only a right to ask.

Why it is in the news

The Court has long said Article 136 should be used sparingly, for grave injustice or important questions of law. In Bihar Legal Support Society v. Chief Justice of India (1986), it observed that it was not meant to function as an ordinary court of appeal. Critics say special leave petitions now fill so much of the docket that constitutional cases are delayed.

Where to go next

Article 130 and the seat of the Supreme Court

The clause that already allows the Court to sit outside Delhi.

In one line: Article 130 says the Supreme Court sits in Delhi or at such other place or places as the Chief Justice of India may appoint with the President's approval.

What it allows

The Article does not fix Delhi as the only seat. It gives the Chief Justice the power to choose other places, subject to the President's approval. Supporters of regional Benches read this as enough legal basis to set up permanent Benches in other cities without amending the Constitution.

Why it has not been used

Successive Chief Justices have been reluctant, arguing that the Supreme Court is one institution and that regional Benches would dilute its authority. The question of a National Court of Appeal, which would need a deeper change, was referred to a Constitution Bench in 2016 and is still pending.

Where to go next

Law Commission's 229th Report

The blueprint for regional Cassation Benches.

In one line: The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed dividing the Supreme Court into a Constitution Bench at Delhi and four Cassation Benches for appeals.

What it proposed

The Commission suggested that a Constitution Bench sit in Delhi to deal with constitutional and allied issues. Four Cassation Benches, in the northern, southern, eastern and western regions, would hear ordinary appeals from the High Courts in their regions. A cassation court reviews whether lower courts applied the law correctly, rather than rehearing facts.

Why it is cited now

With pendency rising despite a larger Court, the report is the main expert document behind the call for regional Benches. The op-ed of 14 November 2026 relies on it, along with Article 130.

Where to go next

Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956

How Parliament decides how many judges the Court has.

In one line: This Act fixes the number of Supreme Court judges other than the Chief Justice; Parliament can change it under Article 124(1).

How the number has grown

The Constitution in 1950 provided for a Chief Justice and seven other judges and left Parliament free to increase the number. The 1956 Act and its amendments raised it in steps. A 2019 amendment raised the number of other judges from 30 to 33, a total of 34. In 2026, an ordinance promulgated on 17 May replaced "33" with "37" in Section 2, making the total 38; Parliament then passed an amending Act.

Why it matters

Because only an ordinary law is needed, raising the Court's size is the easiest reform. The op-ed argues it has not worked: pendency rose from about 60,000 in 2019 to about 92,000 by end-2025, as it cites.

Where to go next

Syllabus

Related stories

Sources used for this summary