Pratidin
2023 · GS2 · 10 marksMains

"Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment.

Question source: insightsonindia.com

Write a timed answer in the app

Current affairs to use in your answer

A Supreme Court judge defends the Collegium and hits back at the Centre · 24 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the example

Use the Collegium row as a current example of how control over appointments is tied to judicial independence from the executive.

  • Supporters argue the Collegium insulates appointments from executive influence, protecting judicial independence, which is part of the basic structure.
  • Justice Dipankar Datta said the clamour against the Collegium was a weak attempt to hide the government's own failure, and the Court called the government's remarks 'disquieting'.
  • Justice Datta argues the government delays or does not act on many Collegium recommendations; note also the pendency of over five crore cases.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Collegium emerged from the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).
  • The 99th Amendment (2014) created the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2015.
  • Articles 124 and 217 govern the appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
Why no 'distinguished jurist' has ever been appointed to the Supreme Court · 2 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the conclusion

Argue that a wider, more diverse pool of judges, including jurists, can strengthen an independent and credible judiciary.

  • Justice Ujjal Bhuyan argued a distinguished jurist 'can be a great value addition to the Bench', helping the Court engage public law questions beyond narrow technicalities, and urged greater Bench diversity.
  • In the Constituent Assembly on 24 May 1949, H.V. Kamath argued appointments should not be confined to judges and practising advocates; sceptics say courtroom experience matters for appeals.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Article 124(3) allows three routes to the Supreme Court: five years as a High Court judge, ten years as a High Court advocate, or being a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
  • No distinguished jurist has ever been appointed; Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raised this at NLU Delhi's 13th convocation on 30 August 2026.
  • The Constituent Assembly debated the route on 24 May 1949; H.V. Kamath pressed for going beyond judges and practising advocates.
Supreme Court asks States to raise district judges' retirement age from 60 to 62 · 5 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the example

Cite the Court's view that judges are not employees to show that distinct service conditions protect judicial independence down to the district level.

  • In All India Judges Association (1993) the Court held: 'The judicial service is not service in the sense of employment. The Judges are not employees.'
  • On 1 September 2026 a Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant directed seven States to raise district judges' retirement age from 60 to 62, citing a separate constitutional scheme under Articles 233 to 235.
  • Extension is subject to a High Court suitability assessment at 60, keeping control of the subordinate judiciary with the High Court rather than the executive.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Supreme Court's order of 1 September 2026 directs seven States to raise the retirement age of district judicial officers from 60 to 62, subject to a High Court suitability assessment at 60.
  • The seven States are Chhattisgarh, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Sikkim, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal; the rest got two weeks to reconsider.
  • The Court cited 5.18 crore cases pending in district courts and persistent vacancies.
Centre issues rules creating a National Tribunals Commission to select tribunal members · 3 October 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the example

Use it to show that judicial independence extends to tribunals, where executive control over appointments was struck down because the government is itself the largest litigant.

  • On 19 November 2025 the Supreme Court struck down key provisions of the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 as violating separation of powers and judicial independence, and directed an independent National Tribunals Commission.
  • The NTC, created by rules dated 30 September 2026, is chaired by a retired Supreme Court judge or High Court Chief Justice and selects members for 16 tribunals and appellate bodies.
  • Critics will watch whether a body whose composition and pay are set by executive rules can be independent in practice.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Rules dated 30 September 2026 create a National Tribunals Commission, headquartered in Delhi, with a chairperson and four members (two judicial, two technical).
  • The NTC chairperson must be a retired Supreme Court judge or a retired High Court Chief Justice; pay is ₹2.5 lakh a month for the chairperson and ₹2.25 lakh for members.
  • The Commission covers selection for 16 tribunals and appellate bodies, and recruitment must begin at least six months before a vacancy arises.

Use it to show that independence depends on who appoints key constitutional officials and on how the Supreme Court organises itself, both under strain in the CEC Act challenge.

  • Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (March 2023) put the CJI on the interim panel appointing the CEC and ECs; the 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a PM-nominated Union Cabinet Minister.
  • Critics say this gives the government a two-to-one majority in choosing those who run elections; supporters say Parliament simply made the law the Court's interim arrangement awaited.
  • The op-ed argues the Chief Justice's power as Master of the Roster, upheld in the 2018 Shanti Bhushan case, needs transparent, pre-settled rules for composing benches.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma split on whether a Constitution Bench must hear the challenge to the CEC and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, and jointly referred the matter to the Chief Justice of India.
  • Article 145(3) requires at least five judges to decide a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution.
  • In Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (March 2023), the Supreme Court set an interim selection committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the Chief Justice of India.
SC says ministry has 'hijacked' NCLT staffing, wants hiring power with tribunal President · 30 October 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the example

Use the NCLT dispute to show that judicial independence extends to tribunals and covers administrative control, not only appointment of judges.

  • The CJI said appointment power over NCLT staff "must be with [NCLT] President only" and that the ministry wanted "complete grip over the institution".
  • The NCLT and NCLAT Presidents were asked to file proposals on staffing and infrastructure within four weeks.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • On 29 October 2026 the Supreme Court said NCLT staffing had been "completely hijacked" by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and that appointment power should lie with the NCLT President.
  • The NCLT and NCLAT Presidents must submit proposals on staffing and infrastructure within four weeks.
  • The MCA says it has only an administrative role in appointing the NCLT's 63 judicial and technical members, and that staff management was delegated to the NCLT on 14 October 2019.
Op-ed: Split the Supreme Court into a constitutional court and regional appeal courts · 14 November 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the conclusion

Argue that judicial independence also depends on the Court having the institutional capacity to decide constitutional questions promptly.

  • Constitution Benches reportedly decided about 134 cases a year in the early 1960s but fewer than 10 a year in the last decade.
  • The 229th Law Commission Report (2009) proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches to protect this role.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Article 130: the Supreme Court sits in Delhi or at other places the CJI appoints with the President's approval.
  • The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed a Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches.
  • The Supreme Court's sanctioned strength rose from 34 to 38 (including the CJI) in 2026, first by an ordinance of 17 May 2026.

Also related

Where it sits in the syllabus

Other questions these stories help answer

  1. 2025 · GS2 · 15 marks Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
  2. 2025 · GS2 · 15 marks "Constitutional morality is the fulcrum which acts as an essential check upon the high functionaries and citizens alike..." In view of the above observation of the Supreme Court, explain the concept…
  3. 2024 · GS2 · 10 marks Explain and distinguish between Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals. Whether they entertain civil as well as criminal cases?
  4. 2018 · GS2 · 15 marks How far do you agree with the view that tribunals curtail the jurisdiction of ordinary courts? In view of the above, discuss the constitutional validity and competency of the tribunals in India.
  5. 2017 · GS2 · 10 marks Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India.
  6. 2017 · Prelims Consider the following statements: 1. The Election Commission of India is a five-member body. 2. Union Ministry of Home Affairs decides the election schedule for the conduct of both general…
  7. 2015 · GS2 · 12.5 marks To achieve the desired objectives, it is necessary to ensure that the regulatory institutions remain independent and autonomous. Discuss in the light of experiences in the recent past.
  8. 2014 · GS2 · 12.5 marks Starting from inventing the 'basic structure' doctrine, the judiciary has played a highly pro active role in ensuring that India develops into a thriving democracy. In light of the statement…