Pratidin
2025 · GS1 · 15 marksMains

Does tribal development in India centre around two axes, those of displacement and of rehabilitation? Give your opinion.

Question source: drishtiias.com

Write a timed answer in the app

Current affairs to use in your answer

Vedanta seeks a return to Niyamgiri, 13 years after gram sabhas said no · 27 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the body

Use Niyamgiri to argue that tribal development also turns on a third axis, community consent through gram sabhas, which here stopped a mining project before it went ahead.

  • In Orissa Mining Corporation v. MoEF (April 2013), the Supreme Court let gram sabhas decide whether mining would affect the Dongria Kondh's religious, cultural and community rights; all 12 rejected it in 2013.
  • The Union Environment Ministry then rejected forest clearance in January 2014, and the project was shelved for about 13 years.
  • In September 2026 Vedanta's Anil Agarwal sought revival and the Odisha CM reportedly assured help; tribal leaders vowed resistance, testing whether a gram sabha 'no' is lasting.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 makes the Gram Sabha the authority to initiate the process of determining individual and community forest rights.
  • The Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA) extends Part IX of the Constitution to Fifth Schedule areas and empowers gram sabhas in those areas.
  • In Orissa Mining Corporation v. Ministry of Environment and Forests (2013), the Supreme Court left the decision on Niyamgiri mining to the gram sabhas of affected villages.
Tribal Affairs Ministry says Forest Rights Act has no provision for gram sabha consent · 7 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the body

Use the gram sabha consent dispute to argue that tribal development hinges on whether communities get a say before displacement, not only on rehabilitation after it.

  • Forest clearance precedes diversion of forest land for projects; a 3 August 2009 Environment Ministry circular required States to certify FRA rights were settled, with gram sabha consent.
  • Parliament's Committee on Public Undertakings found clearances averaged 106 months and recommended 70 to 75% 'qualified super-majority consent' of affected gram sabhas for large hydropower projects.
  • Way forward: settle FRA claims first and in time, adopt a single time-bound consent rule, and ensure fair benefit sharing and rehabilitation to make consent easier to give.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Ministry of Tribal Affairs, nodal ministry for the Forest Rights Act, 2006, says the Act and its rules contain no provision for gram sabha consent for Stage-II forest clearance.
  • Parliament's Committee on Public Undertakings recommended 'qualified super-majority consent' of 70 to 75% of affected gram sabhas for large hydropower projects of national importance.
  • Under Section 6 of the FRA, the gram sabha is the authority to initiate the process of determining individual and community forest rights.
Editorial: The push to dilute gram sabha consent for forest diversion · 9 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the body

The consent debate shows that the key tribal question is whether communities can refuse displacement, not only how they are rehabilitated afterwards.

  • Parliament's Committee on Public Undertakings suggested a 70 to 75% consent threshold among affected gram sabhas for large hydropower projects, citing 106-month forest clearance delays for NHPC projects.
  • The Hindu's editorial argues a threshold would let a village losing sacred groves or ancestral land be outvoted by villages only marginally affected.
  • Way forward: complete rights settlement before diversion, time-bound gram sabha meetings with translated documents, and better benefit-sharing and rehabilitation.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Ministry of Tribal Affairs has told the Ministry of Power that the Forest Rights Act, 2006 has no provision for gram sabha consent for Stage-II forest clearance.
  • Parliament's Committee on Public Undertakings recommended exploring a 70 to 75% consent threshold among affected gram sabhas for large hydropower projects of national importance, in place of 100%.
  • Forest diversion under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 is approved in two stages: Stage-I (in-principle) and Stage-II (final).
Arunachal CM tells Siang dam protesters no decision without consultation and consent · 3 November 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the example

Use the Siang protests to show that displacement remains the central fear in tribal areas, and that consent is becoming a third axis beyond displacement and rehabilitation.

  • Adi groups oppose the 11,200 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project over submergence of ancestral villages, loss of farmland, forests and livelihoods.
  • Protests turned violent in September and on 23 October 2026, when an NHPC office and a police station in Pasighat were burnt.
  • On 2 November 2026 the Arunachal CM promised no decision without detailed public consultation and the consent of affected people.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Siang Upper Multipurpose Project is a proposed 11,200 MW project on the Siang in Arunachal Pradesh, declared a National Project on 7 February 2008.
  • On 2 November 2026 CM Pema Khandu said no construction decision has been taken and none will be without public consultation and consent of affected people.
  • The project is at the pre-feasibility stage; a Social Impact Assessment, Environmental Impact Assessment and Detailed Project Report would follow if it is viable.

Also related

Where it sits in the syllabus

Other questions these stories help answer

  1. 2025 · GS3 · 15 marks Mineral resources are fundamental to the country's economy and these are exploited by mining. Why is mining considered an environmental hazard? Explain the remedial measures required to reduce the…
  2. 2024 · GS3 · 15 marks India has a long and troubled border with China and Pakistan fraught with contentious issues. Examine the conflicting issues and security challenges along the border. Also give out the development…
  3. 2023 · GS3 · 10 marks Dam failures are always catastrophic, especially on the downstream side, resulting in a colossal loss of life and property. Analyze the various causes of dam failures. Give two examples of large dam…
  4. 2022 · GS3 · 15 marks Naxalism is a social, economic and developmental issue manifesting as a violent internal security threat. In this context, discuss the emerging issues and suggest a multilayered strategy to tackle…
  5. 2018 · GS3 · 10 marks Left-wing extremism (LWE) is showing a downward trend but still affects many parts of the country. Briefly explain the Government of India's approach to counter the challenges posed by LWE.
  6. 2017 · GS1 · 10 marks What are the two major legal initiatives by the State since Independence addressing discrimination against Scheduled Tribes (STs)?
  7. 2015 · Prelims The provisions in Fifth Schedule and Sixth Schedule in the Constitution of India are made in order to (a) protect the interests of Scheduled Tribes (b) determine the boundaries between States (c)…
  8. 2015 · Prelims The fundamental object of Panchayati Raj system is to ensure which among the following? 1. People's participation in development 2. Political accountability 3. Democratic decentralization 4…