Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
Question source: insightsonindia.com
Write a timed answer in the appCurrent affairs to use in your answer
Supplies the evolution of the Collegium, its defence and its criticisms for the Indian half of the answer.
- Under Articles 124 and 217, the Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases turned 'consultation' into 'concurrence', creating the Collegium; the 99th Amendment's NJAC (2014) was struck down in 2015.
- Justice Dipankar Datta argues 'judges appointing judges' is misleading because the government delays recommendations; he said in 2025 that his 2019 Calcutta High Court recommendation was still pending.
- Opacity is a key weakness: Justice Datta remarked in March 2026 that even judges often do not know when the Collegium meets, and the Memorandum of Procedure remains unfinalised.
- The Collegium emerged from the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).
- The 99th Amendment (2014) created the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2015.
- Articles 124 and 217 govern the appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
Use the unused jurist route to add an eligibility dimension to the India-USA comparison: India's collegium draws only from judges and advocates, while the US has appointed academics.
- Article 124(3) allows appointment of a High Court judge of five years, a High Court advocate of ten years, or a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion; the third route has never been used.
- Under the Third Judges case (1998), the collegium is the CJI and four senior-most judges; it habitually chooses from High Courts and the Bar.
- Justice Ujjal Bhuyan (30 August 2026) cited Felix Frankfurter, a Harvard law professor who became a US Supreme Court judge, and academic appointments in the UK, Canada and Kenya.
- Article 124(3) allows three routes to the Supreme Court: five years as a High Court judge, ten years as a High Court advocate, or being a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
- No distinguished jurist has ever been appointed; Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raised this at NLU Delhi's 13th convocation on 30 August 2026.
- The Constituent Assembly debated the route on 24 May 1949; H.V. Kamath pressed for going beyond judges and practising advocates.
Use the Punjab dispute as a current example of how the collegium system works for High Court Chief Justices and where the executive and States fit.
- After the Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases, a High Court Chief Justice is recommended by a collegium of the CJI and the two senior-most Supreme Court judges.
- Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra was recommended on 6 August and notified on 5 September 2026; Punjab's Cabinet sought a hold, saying its views were not obtained under the MoP.
- Article 217 requires consultation with the CJI and Governor; the MoP asks for State views but sets no time limit, and follows a policy of appointing Chief Justices from outside the State.
- Article 217(1) requires the President to consult the Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State before appointing a High Court judge, and also the High Court's Chief Justice for judges other than the Chief Justice.
- For a common High Court, Article 231 makes the reference to the Governor in Article 217 mean the Governors of all the States over which the court has jurisdiction.
- Under the collegium system, a High Court Chief Justice is recommended by the CJI and the two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court, and the MoP's policy is to appoint Chief Justices from outside the State.
Where it sits in the syllabus
- GS2: Executive, judiciary, pressure groups
Structure, organization and functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary; Ministries and Departments of the Government; pressure groups and formal/informal associations and their role in the Polity.
- GS2: Separation of powers, dispute redressal
Separation of powers between various organs, dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.
- GS2: Constitution: evolution, features, basic structure
Indian Constitution: historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.
- GS2: Federalism and devolution
Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.
Other questions these stories help answer
- 2025 · GS2 · 15 marks "Constitutional morality is the fulcrum which acts as an essential check upon the high functionaries and citizens alike..." In view of the above observation of the Supreme Court, explain the concept…
- 2023 · GS2 · 10 marks "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment.
- 2017 · GS2 · 10 marks Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India.