Pratidin
2017 · GS2 · 10 marksMains

Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India.

Question source: insightsonindia.com

Write a timed answer in the app

Current affairs to use in your answer

A Supreme Court judge defends the Collegium and hits back at the Centre · 24 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the body

Gives the grounds and aftermath of the NJAC judgment, showing that the appointment dispute it settled remains alive.

  • The 99th Amendment (2014) created the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2015.
  • Note that the Court struck it down because it gave the executive and non-judicial members a potential veto over appointments.
  • The 2015 judgment suggested a permanent secretariat to assess candidates, yet the Memorandum of Procedure has still not been finalised and the Centre-judiciary dispute continues.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • The Collegium emerged from the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).
  • The 99th Amendment (2014) created the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2015.
  • Articles 124 and 217 govern the appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
Why no 'distinguished jurist' has ever been appointed to the Supreme Court · 2 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the conclusion

Use the jurist debate to suggest that, within the collegium-led system, appointments need transparent criteria and a wider pool.

  • No distinguished jurist has been appointed in 76 years; reasons include the collegium's habit of choosing from High Courts and the Bar and the undefined meaning of 'distinguished'.
  • Way forward: set transparent criteria for 'distinguished jurist' in the memorandum of procedure, so the collegium can look beyond High Court judges and advocates.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Article 124(3) allows three routes to the Supreme Court: five years as a High Court judge, ten years as a High Court advocate, or being a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
  • No distinguished jurist has ever been appointed; Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raised this at NLU Delhi's 13th convocation on 30 August 2026.
  • The Constituent Assembly debated the route on 24 May 1949; H.V. Kamath pressed for going beyond judges and practising advocates.
Punjab asks Centre to hold High Court Chief Justice appointment, citing MoP breach · 7 September 2026 · Covers one part · use it in the conclusion

Use the Punjab episode to show that, with the collegium in place, gaps in the Memorandum of Procedure still cause friction, and to propose MoP reform.

  • Under the collegium, primacy rests with the judiciary's opinion, and the State's role in High Court appointments is only consultative.
  • Punjab says the Centre notified its High Court Chief Justice without its views, because the MoP sets no time limit for them; the Bar Association called the demand executive interference.
  • Reform the MoP: fix timelines for State views, after which the file proceeds, and record reasons when State objections are overruled.
Facts from this story you can cite
  • Article 217(1) requires the President to consult the Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State before appointing a High Court judge, and also the High Court's Chief Justice for judges other than the Chief Justice.
  • For a common High Court, Article 231 makes the reference to the Governor in Article 217 mean the Governors of all the States over which the court has jurisdiction.
  • Under the collegium system, a High Court Chief Justice is recommended by the CJI and the two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court, and the MoP's policy is to appoint Chief Justices from outside the State.

Where it sits in the syllabus

Other questions these stories help answer

  1. 2025 · GS2 · 15 marks Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
  2. 2025 · GS2 · 15 marks "Constitutional morality is the fulcrum which acts as an essential check upon the high functionaries and citizens alike..." In view of the above observation of the Supreme Court, explain the concept…
  3. 2023 · GS2 · 10 marks "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment.