Discuss how the contradiction between ‘rapid infrastructure development’ and ‘disaster-risk reduction’ in ecologically-sensitive areas of India can be managed, with suitable examples. (Answer in 150 words)
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The conflict between building fast and reducing disaster risk in fragile Himalayan and Western Ghats landscapes can be managed by planning infrastructure around hazard and carrying-capacity assessments, enforcing eco-sensitive zoning, designing for resilience, and monitoring projects, drawing on the experience of Joshimath (2023), Silkyara (2023) and Wayanad (2024).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Discuss' needs both sides: why infrastructure in these areas is needed and why it can raise risk, followed by concrete ways to reconcile the two, each supported by Indian examples and legal or institutional tools.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ecologically-sensitive areas such as the Himalaya and Western Ghats need roads, tunnels, hydropower and towns for connectivity, defence and livelihoods, but steep slopes, young geology and heavy rain make poorly planned construction a direct cause of disasters.
Why the contradiction arises
- Strategic and economic need: the Supreme Court on 14 December 2021 allowed double-lane widening (10 m tarred surface) of three strategic roads in the Char Dham project for defence needs.
- Risk created by construction: slope cutting, blasting, tunnelling and debris dumping weaken slopes and block drainage.
- Joshimath: cracks in hundreds of buildings led to evacuations, and demolition of unsafe structures began on 9 January 2023.
- Silkyara Bend-Barkot tunnel collapse in Uttarkashi on 12 November 2023 trapped 41 workers, rescued on 28 November 2023.
- Wayanad landslides of 30 July 2024 killed over 300 people.
How it can be managed
- Risk-informed planning: geological and hazard mapping, carrying-capacity studies and cumulative impact assessment before approving clusters of projects.
- Zoning: Eco-Sensitive Area notifications under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; the draft of 31 July 2024 proposes 56,825.7 sq km of the Western Ghats in six states as ESA, with bans on mining, quarrying and new thermal plants.
- Resilient design: escape tunnels, slope stabilisation, scientific muck disposal and drainage built into project cost.
- Independent oversight: the Supreme Court set up an oversight committee under Justice A K Sikri for the Char Dham project.
- Early warning, community preparedness and building codes enforced by local bodies.
- Global frameworks: Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015-2030.
Conclusion
Development and safety are not opposites if risk is priced into project design and approval; in fragile zones, the rule should be fewer, better-designed projects with strong monitoring rather than speed alone.
Examples and data to cite
- Supreme Court, Ministry of Defence application in the Char Dham case, 14 December 2021 (Justices D Y Chandrachud, Surya Kant, Vikram Nath)
- Joshimath land subsidence and demolitions, January 2023
- Silkyara tunnel collapse, 12 to 28 November 2023
- Wayanad landslides, 30 July 2024
- Western Ghats ESA draft notification, 31 July 2024, 56,825.7 sq km in six states
Facts to remember
- The Char Dham judgment allowed a 10 m tarred surface instead of the earlier 5.5 m limit on the three strategic roads.
- The 2024 Western Ghats draft was the sixth since 10 March 2014.
- The Sendai Framework runs from 2015 to 2030.
- Eco-Sensitive Areas are notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
Question source: insightsonindia.com
Write a timed answer in the appCurrent affairs to use in your answer
Gives a live case of the clash between local development needs and disaster-risk reduction in the Western Ghats, with a workable compromise.
- On 22 September Karnataka's legislature rejected, in its present form, the Centre's seventh draft ESA notification (27 July 2026), which covers about 20,668 sq km and 1,449 villages in 10 districts.
- Landslides and floods in Kerala (2018) and Wayanad (2024) have been linked to quarrying and land-use change, the cost of delaying protection.
- Suggest a compromise: village-level ground truthing, regulating harmful activities rather than all development, payments for ecosystem services and gram sabha participation.
- The Gadgil panel (WGEEP, 2011) proposed treating about 64% of the Western Ghats as ecologically sensitive.
- The Kasturirangan working group (2013) reduced this to about 37%, focusing on natural landscapes.
- Eco-sensitive areas are notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; the Centre has issued several draft notifications without a final one.
Use GLOF preparedness to show how hazard risk must be built into infrastructure planning in the Himalaya, with the Chungthang breach as the warning.
- In October 2023 the South Lhonak lake outburst in Sikkim sent a flood down the Teesta that breached the Chungthang dam.
- On 3 September 2026 the Union Home Secretary asked Himalayan States to shift from response to 'risk-informed planning, preventive mitigation and community-level preparedness'.
- Hazard is often not built into approvals for dams and roads; require risk assessment of all infrastructure downstream of glacial lakes.
- On 3 September 2026, Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan reviewed GLOF and avalanche preparedness of Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir.
- States were asked to shift to risk-informed planning, preventive mitigation and community-level preparedness, and to speed up GLOF mitigation projects sanctioned in 2024.
- The National GLOF Risk Mitigation Project (₹150 crore, approved August 2024) covers Arunachal Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Sikkim and Uttarakhand and targets 189 high-risk lakes.
Use the Trishuli valley flood to show how infrastructure in fragile mountain valleys is exposed to glacial hazards, and what risk-sensitive development requires.
- The 26 August 2026 flood destroyed the Gyirong port crossing on the Nepal-China border and damaged 13 hydropower projects along a 72 km stretch of the Trishuli river.
- Risk-sensitive development: climate-proof hydropower and border infrastructure in high-risk valleys, and invest in early warning and glacial lake monitoring with data shared across the Himalaya, including with China and India.
- A glacier collapse near Langtang Lirung on 26 August 2026 caused a flood down the Trishuli river in Nepal, destroying the Gyirong border crossing with China.
- Nepal has said it will seek compensation, not aid, from major emitters, and has written to the UN's Loss and Damage Fund.
- The Loss and Damage Fund was agreed at the 2022 UN climate conference (COP27) and relies on voluntary pledges, reported at about $822 million.
Use the warming-Himalaya evidence and the committees' recommendations to show how development and disaster-risk reduction can be reconciled through siting, monitoring and cumulative assessment.
- ICIMOD (March 2026): Hindu Kush Himalaya ice-loss rates have doubled since 2000; glaciers lost 12% area between 1990 and 2020.
- Ravi Chopra expert body, after Kedarnath 2013, found 23 of 24 projects in Alaknanda and Bhagirathi basins would cause irreversible impact.
- Tools: satellite and sensor surveillance, engineered drainage of glacial lakes, flood zoning by valley slope, basin-level impact studies.
- ICIMOD reports released on 21 March 2026 found ice-loss rates in the Hindu Kush Himalaya have doubled since 2000.
- From 1990 to 2020, Hindu Kush Himalayan glaciers lost about 12% of their area and 9% of their estimated ice reserves.
- On 26 August 2026 an ice and rock collapse near Langtang Lirung in Nepal dammed the Lhende Khola and caused a flash flood.
Cite Nepal's August 2026 disaster to show how infrastructure in narrow Himalayan valleys raises disaster losses, strengthening the case for risk-sensitive planning.
- The 26 August 2026 debris flow down the Bhotekoshi-Trishuli-Narayani system destroyed hydropower plants, bridges and roads.
- Nepal's recovery needs of at least $4.71 billion dwarf the $20 million loss and damage allocation, showing why prevention costs less than rebuilding.
- On 22 October 2026 the FRLD board set aside $20 million (plus $1.6 million in fees) for Nepal, its first allocation.
- Nepal's 26 August 2026 rock-ice avalanche and floods killed more than 1,400 people; recovery needs are at least $4.71 billion.
- The FRLD was agreed at COP27 (2022), operationalised at COP28 (2023) and is hosted on an interim basis by the World Bank.
Cite Badrinath as an ecologically sensitive area where new infrastructure sits in hazard zones, and show how hazard mapping can guide where to build.
- A 2026 study found ice avalanches from three hanging glaciers could reach about 398 buildings and a helipad in Badrinath.
- The Chamoli disaster of 7 February 2021 damaged two hydropower projects and left over 200 dead or missing.
- Experts recommend early warning and keeping new construction out of modelled flow paths.
- A study in the journal Landslides (online 28 October 2026) found that ice avalanches from three hanging glaciers could reach about 398 buildings in Badrinath.
- The study was by researchers from IISc's Divecha Centre for Climate Change, DRDO's Defence Geoinformatics Research Establishment and the University of Cambridge.
- An April 2026 inventory found 219 hanging glaciers in the Alaknanda basin, holding about 0.74 cubic km of hanging ice.
Also related
- Madhav Gadgil Panel (WGEEP)
The WGEEP's zoning of the Ghats into ecologically sensitive zones is the model for reconciling infrastructure with disaster-risk reduction.
In brief- About 64% of the Western Ghats to be treated as ecologically sensitive.
- Kasturirangan Working Group
The Kasturirangan group narrowed the ecologically sensitive area to about 37% and allowed regulated development elsewhere; ESA notifications remain unsettled.
In brief- About 37% of the Western Ghats as ecologically sensitive.
- Karnataka seeks ₹7,142.64 crore in Central drought aid for 177 taluks 4 October 2026
Mitigation spending under the 15th Finance Commission's disaster funds is part of the answer on reducing disaster risk.
Facts from this story you can cite- Karnataka sought ₹7,142.64 crore from the NDRF on 3 October 2026 for drought in 177 taluks, against estimated losses of ₹46,324.50 crore.
- Rainfall from 1 June to 16 September 2026 was 495 mm against a normal of 766 mm, a 35% deficit.
- Drought is declared by State governments using the Manual for Drought Management (updated 2020): rainfall triggers, impact indicators and ground truthing.
- Andhra Pradesh braces for Cyclone Murasu, its second cyclone in a week 2 November 2026
Concerns disaster-risk reduction alongside infrastructure; the story's resilient-infrastructure points are relevant but it is not about ecologically sensitive areas.
Facts from this story you can cite- Cyclonic Storm Murasu formed over the Bay of Bengal on 1 November 2026, days after Cyclone Arnab hit Andhra Pradesh.
- Murasu, a Tamil word for a traditional drum, was contributed by India; Arnab was Bangladesh's name.
- The North Indian Ocean list has 169 names from 13 countries, adopted in 2020; names are at most eight letters and never reused.
Where it sits in the syllabus
- GS3: Conservation, pollution, EIA
Conservation, environmental pollution and degradation, environmental impact assessment.
- GS3: Disaster management
Disaster and disaster management.
- GS3: Infrastructure
Infrastructure: Energy, Ports, Roads, Airports, Railways etc.
Other questions these stories help answer
- 2025 · GS3 · 15 marks Mineral resources are fundamental to the country's economy and these are exploited by mining. Why is mining considered an environmental hazard? Explain the remedial measures required to reduce the…
- 2025 · GS1 · 15 marks Achieving sustainable growth with emphasis on environmental protection could come into conflict with poor people's needs in a country like India. Comment.
- 2024 · GS2 · 15 marks What changes has the Union Government recently introduced in the domain of Centre-State relations? Suggest measures to be adopted to build the trust between the Centre and the States and for…
- 2023 · GS3 · 10 marks Dam failures are always catastrophic, especially on the downstream side, resulting in a colossal loss of life and property. Analyze the various causes of dam failures. Give two examples of large dam…
- 2021 · GS1 · 10 marks Differentiate the causes of landslides in the Himalayan region and Western Ghats.
- 2020 · GS3 · 10 marks How does the draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2020 differ from the existing EIA Notification, 2006?
- 2019 · Prelims Consider the following pairs: Glacier : River 1. Bandarpunch : Yamuna 2. Bara Shigri : Chenab 3. Milam : Mandakini 4. Siachen : Nubra 5. Zemu : Manas Which of the pairs given above are correctly…
- 2017 · GS3 · 15 marks 'Climate Change' is a global problem. How India will be affected by climate change? How Himalayan and coastal states of India will be affected by climate change?