How far do you agree with the view that tribunals curtail the jurisdiction of ordinary courts? In view of the above, discuss the constitutional validity and competency of the tribunals in India.
Question source: clearias.com
Write a timed answer in the appCurrent affairs to use in your answer
Use it to show that tribunals are constitutionally valid but cannot oust judicial review, and that courts have repeatedly policed executive control over them, most recently leading to the National Tribunals Commission.
- Articles 323A and 323B, added by the 42nd Amendment of 1976, allow tribunals for specialised disputes such as service matters, tax, company law and environment.
- L. Chandra Kumar (1997), a seven-judge bench, held High Court and Supreme Court judicial review part of the basic structure, so a law cannot exclude High Court jurisdiction without an alternative arrangement.
- On 19 November 2025 the Supreme Court struck down key provisions of the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 for violating separation of powers and judicial independence, leading to NTC Rules dated 30 September 2026.
- Rules dated 30 September 2026 create a National Tribunals Commission, headquartered in Delhi, with a chairperson and four members (two judicial, two technical).
- The NTC chairperson must be a retired Supreme Court judge or a retired High Court Chief Justice; pay is ₹2.5 lakh a month for the chairperson and ₹2.25 lakh for members.
- The Commission covers selection for 16 tribunals and appellate bodies, and recruitment must begin at least six months before a vacancy arises.
Show that tribunal validity depends on independence equal to courts, and that executive control over staff and resources undermines it, using the NCLT case.
- Part XIV-A (Articles 323A and 323B), added by the 42nd Amendment of 1976, allows tribunals; the NCLT is a statutory tribunal under the Companies Act, 2013.
- On 19 November 2025 the Supreme Court struck down the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 and ordered a National Tribunal Commission within four months.
- On 29 October 2026 the Court said NCLT staffing was "completely hijacked" by the MCA and wanted appointment power with the NCLT President.
- On 29 October 2026 the Supreme Court said NCLT staffing had been "completely hijacked" by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and that appointment power should lie with the NCLT President.
- The NCLT and NCLAT Presidents must submit proposals on staffing and infrastructure within four weeks.
- The MCA says it has only an administrative role in appointing the NCLT's 63 judicial and technical members, and that staff management was delegated to the NCLT on 14 October 2019.
Cite the SIR tribunals as a case where a tribunal expanded access to justice, but whose competence depends on staffing.
- 19 tribunals of retired judges were notified in March 2026 for West Bengal's SIR appeals under a Supreme Court order.
- Resignations of four judges, citing workload and travel, have stalled appeals in Murshidabad.
- Retired judge Biswajit Basu is the fourth of 19 retired judges to quit the West Bengal SIR appellate tribunals.
- The West Bengal SIR deleted nearly 91 lakh voters from the electoral rolls.
- On 10 March 2026, the Supreme Court ordered appellate tribunals of former High Court judges for SIR exclusions in West Bengal; the EC notified 19 tribunals in March.
Use the Yamuna floodplain ruling as an example of the Supreme Court correcting a tribunal's errors of law and jurisdiction, showing tribunals do not escape judicial oversight.
- On 22 August 2026 the Supreme Court set aside the NGT's 2017 judgment holding a festival organiser liable for Yamuna floodplain damage.
- It held the NGT misapplied no-fault liability under Section 17(3) and exceeded Section 15 by ordering floodplain rehabilitation.
- It faulted the NGT for treating its 9 March 2016 interim findings as final without re-examining full evidence.
- On 22 August 2026 the Supreme Court set aside the NGT's 7 December 2017 judgment holding Vyakti Vikas Kendra India liable for Yamuna floodplain damage from the March 2016 World Culture Festival.
- The DDA was told to refund the ₹5 crore deposit within four weeks; the Court said liability needs a causal link between the polluter's conduct and the damage.
- Section 17(3) of the NGT Act, 2010 applies the principle of no fault in case of an accident; Section 20 makes the NGT apply sustainable development, the precautionary principle and polluter pays.
Also related
- Justice Nagarathna: family disputes need mediation and adjudication working together 27 September 2026
The family court debate is the same question from another angle: specialised or alternative forums can speed up justice, but ordinary courts remain the guarantor of rights.
Facts from this story you can cite- The Family Courts Act, 1984 provides for family courts and, under Section 9, requires them to first make efforts to bring about a settlement between the parties.
- The Mediation Act, 2023 gives mediation a statutory framework and provides for pre-litigation mediation under Section 5.
- Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 allows a court to refer a dispute to arbitration, conciliation, judicial settlement including a Lok Adalat, or mediation.
- At NGT's climate conference, Modi says developing nations are wrongly blamed for emissions 20 September 2026
The NGT is the prime example of a specialised tribunal whose orders go directly to the Supreme Court, relevant to the debate on tribunals and ordinary courts.
Facts from this story you can cite- PM Modi told an NGT-organised conference on 19 September 2026 that responsibility for carbon emissions has been wrongly placed on developing countries.
- He said India's per capita carbon emissions are less than half the global average and that developed countries' per capita emissions are six times India's.
- India's solar capacity has risen from about 2 GW to more than 160 GW in twelve years, according to the PM.
- CJI asks why litigants rush to the Supreme Court for early hearings in High Court cases 2 November 2026
Both concern how jurisdiction is shared among courts; L. Chandra Kumar, relevant to tribunals, also anchors the Article 226 discussion here.
Facts from this story you can cite- CJI Surya Kant flagged a growing trend of litigants asking the Supreme Court to order early hearings in High Court cases.
- He said the Supreme Court respects High Courts' control over their rosters but listing must become transparent and predictable.
- Article 226 gives High Courts writ power for fundamental and other legal rights, wider than Article 32.
Where it sits in the syllabus
- GS2: Separation of powers, dispute redressal
Separation of powers between various organs, dispute redressal mechanisms and institutions.
- GS2: Executive, judiciary, pressure groups
Structure, organization and functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary; Ministries and Departments of the Government; pressure groups and formal/informal associations and their role in the Polity.
- GS2: Statutory, regulatory, quasi-judicial bodies
Statutory, regulatory and various quasi-judicial bodies.
- GS2: Constitution: evolution, features, basic structure
Indian Constitution: historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.
- GS2: Representation of the People Act
Salient features of the Representation of People's Act.
- GS2: Constitutional posts and bodies
Appointment to various Constitutional posts, powers, functions and responsibilities of various Constitutional Bodies.
Other questions these stories help answer
- 2026 · GS2 · 10 marks Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship…
- 2025 · GS1 · 15 marks Achieving sustainable growth with emphasis on environmental protection could come into conflict with poor people's needs in a country like India. Comment.
- 2024 · GS2 · 10 marks Explain and distinguish between Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals. Whether they entertain civil as well as criminal cases?
- 2023 · GS2 · 10 marks "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment.
- 2022 · GS2 · 15 marks 'Clean energy is the order of the day.' Describe briefly India's changing policy towards climate change in various international fora in the context of geopolitics.
- 2020 · Prelims In India, Legal Services Authorities provide free legal services to which of the following type of citizens? 1. Person with an annual income of less than Rs 1,00,000 2. Transgender with an annual…
- 2018 · Prelims How is the National Green Tribunal (NGT) different from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)? 1. The NGT has been established by an Act whereas the CPCB has been created by executive order of…
- 2017 · Prelims Consider the following statements: 1. The Election Commission of India is a five-member body. 2. Union Ministry of Home Affairs decides the election schedule for the conduct of both general…